"This Easy Broiled Lobster Tail Recipe is ready in about 10 minutes and is tender, buttery and delicious! Don't let those lobster tails scare you, they're actually super easy to make and are a sure way to impress at the dinner table. How To Cook The Perfect Lobster Tails In the Oven: The key, as with most seafood, is to not overcook the lobster. If you overcook the lobster it can turn out chewy and have a fishy smell to it, which is unfortunate because lobster tails aren't necessarily cheap. You're going to want to ..."