Buttery and sweet, thumbprint cookies are a classic holiday cookie. It gets its name because an indentation is made in the middle of the cookie. Traditionally they’re filled with jam, but can also be filled with other goodies. From traditional to ones with a twist, we’re sharing six thumbprint cookie recipes that will be a festive addition to any holiday cookie tray.
Gingerbread Thumbprints
“This is a mix of several great gingerbread cookie recipes. I added the white chocolate glaze for an extra touch! They have become a favorite during my holiday baking.” – Kelly
Thumbprint Cookies The Ultimate Best!
“This is the only thumbprint cookie recipe I will ever use. They turn out delicate and delectable! Other recipes yield dry and tasteless cookies…. not this recipe! This one has never failed me. Feel free to double this recipe as you will want more!” – Deb
Ultimate Cookie Lover’s Thumbprints
“These go perfectly on a holiday cookie tray and would surely even make Santa very happy!” – Crystal
Cocoa Thumbprint Cookies
“I made these specifically for my brother. His buddy’s dog got a hold of the container the cookies were in and only left him with 3 cookies. He was so mad.” – Sara
Butter Cookies (Swedish)
“These were a staple of holiday cookies in my childhood. My great grandmother, grandmother, mom, and I would make them together. As the child, I had the job of using a thimble to make the perfect dent to fill with sparkling jellies.” – Wendy
Chocolate Cherry Thumbprint Cookies
“The secret to these great cookies is the oatmeal and the melted chocolate chips. Being my husband’s favorite cookies from childhood, I have perfected the recipe since my mother-in-law gave it to me years ago.” – Katrina