1. Cream Cheese Cake Mix Cookies – 32,255 pinches
So good, so easy, these chocolate chip cookies take the cake 😉 Deliciously sweet and buttery, you won’t be able to get enough of these amazingly tasty treats!
2. PEGGI’S GIGANTIC, MELT IN YOUR MOUTH, CRISPY PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES – 12,534 pinches
You’ll be sooooo glad you tried these cookies! Delightfully sweet and perfectly peanut buttery, they will melt in your mouth…yummmmm.
3. Gooey Butter Cookies -12,382 pinches
Super easy to make and loved by all! Crunchy on the outside, gooey in the middle – just a few simple steps to enjoy these scrumptious cookies!
4. Best Chocolate Chip Cookies – 10,801 pinches
Vanilla pudding in your chocolate chip cookies = heavenly! Kids of all ages will gobble these chocolate chip cookies up, plus just 3 simple steps to whip up a batch!
5. PMS Cookies – 10,787 pinches
A bit of chocolate, a bit of salt, a bit of peanut butter – ladies this is everything you need during anytime (especially that time) of the month! Cravings be gone and just freeze some in case of emergencies!
6. Magic in the Middle Cookies – 9,622 pinches
Melt in your mouth with every bite – these cake-like cookies truly are magic. The peanut butter filling just tops this recipe off to make it one of our favorites!
7. Grandma Helen’s Oatmeal Cookies – 9,143 pinches
Make these traditional oatmeal cookies 100% your own by adding your favorite ingredients. From coconut to chocolate chips to raisins to peanut butter – you’re sure to love this mix of flavors!
8. Coconut-Pecan Cookies
Pecan Sandies meet Snickerdoodles!! Moist and chewy, these cookies are super tasty. We can guarantee you’ll love them!
9. “Melt in your Mouth” Toffee Pecan Cookies – 8,633 pinches
4 seriously easy steps to make these melt-in-your-mouth cookies! The only bad thing about these cookies is that it’s impossible to eat just one!
10. Dishpan Cookies – 8,543 pinches
Savory, sweet and chewy in every bite! Just a few easy steps to make these tasty treats. And let’s be real, you can never have too many cookies – making dishpan cookies the best!
11. Peanut Butter~Peanut Butter Chip Cookies – 7,877 pinches
A combo of two of our favorites, peanut butter cookies + chocolate chip cookies … needless to say they are delish! Seriously out-of-this-world flavor, kids of all ages will go wild for these!
12. Oatmeal Double Chocolate Chip Cookies – 7,532 pinches
Extra chocolate? More like extra yum! Truly delightful,this cookie was made for chocolate lovers! Pro tip: splurge for high-quality chocolate, you won’t be disappointed!
13. Bacon Chocolate Chip Cookies! – 7,150 pinches
Umm…bacon in a cookie? Sign us up twice! A perfect meld of flavors, the crispy bacon plus the chocolate chips, we can’t even. Nom!
14. Thumb Print Cookies The Ultimate best! – 7,132 pinches
Original to every cook who makes them,these cookies turn out delicate and delectable! We’re sure the kiddos will love to lend a thumb to make them!
15. Not Your Mama’s Cookies! – 7,062
Peanut butter chips + mini pretzels + sea salt + dark chocolate = the perfect sweet and salty combo. Our mouths are watering just thinking about it…